Pulse Music – Steve Reich: Pendulum Music (1968)

by Ben Hogwood

““In many ways, you could describe Pendulum Music as audible sculpture”– Steve Reich, talking to Michael Nyman in 1976 (from Steve Reich: Writings on Music: 1965-2000)

Background

Writings On Music details another elemental discovery made by Reich that led to the composition of this short piece, whereby “he began to twirl a microphone cord like a lasso in William T. Wiley’s Boulder studio and discovered the effect of its feedback as it crossed the path of a speaker. It was incorporated into the performance accompanying a snowfall (of Ivory Snow flakes) in black light. The directions, laid out in Writings On Music, are clear:

“2, 3, 4 or more microphones are suspended from the ceiling by their cables so that they all hang the same distance from the floor and are all free to swing with a pendular motion. Each microphone’s cable is plugged into an amplifier which is connected to a speaker. Each microphone hangs a few inches directly above or next to its speaker.”

Each of the performers pulls back their microphone like a swing and releases them together, at which point the amplifiers are turned up to the point where feedback occurs when the microphone swings over or next to its speaker. Feedback pulses are heard, creating the music – during which the performers sit along with the audience to hear the piece work itself out in real time. When each microphone comes to rest with a continuous tone the amplifiers are switched off in unison and the piece ends.

“It can be performed best on small, inexpensive loudspeakers where you get a series of ‘bird calls’ and I much prefer that to hi-fi shriek”, says Reich. “Pendulum Music should be short and amusing.”

Listen

To appreciate it fully an audio-visual experience such as this is encouraged

Thoughts

The audio-visual experience for Pendulum Music is essential; because without it the piece is disorientating and not entirely satisfying. There is a fascination, however, in following the way the music evolves, like a bicycle freewheeling down a hill before it plateaus. The further it travels the more energy and speed is lost, until the time where it is unable to move or make a tune. The mood then becomes listless to the point of complete inactivity.

No two performances of Pendulum Music are the same, heightening the fascination, though after the ear has determined the sounds and colours it ultimately wills the music to stop, long before it comes to rest, meaning the experience can be frustrating if the piece goes on for longer!

As we travel through Reich’s output, we will see this technique of phrase elongation put to more effective use.

Quotes / Legacy

The piece was first presented in Colorado in 1968, but its standout performance came at the Whitney Museum of American Art in May 1969. Reich appears to have seen it as a necessary piece but one with no particular future.

To Nyman, he said, “I would say that the relationship between Serra and me is lodged in Pendulum Music. I gave him the original score of Pendulum Music as a gift; in exchange, he gave me a piece called Candle Rock, which is simply a piece of wood with 10 holes drilled in it that holds candles and sits on the floor. Actually, my ensemble rarely performs Pendulum Music anymore.”

Recordings

Ensemble Avantgarde, recording for Wergo, capture the playfulness of the piece much more than other accounts – particularly Sonic Youth, whose striking version nonetheless gets the ‘hi-fi shriek’ that Reich was keen to avoid:

You can listen to three available recordings of Pendulum Music on this Tidal playlist

Also written / released in 1968 The Beatles The Beatles (The White Album); The Jimi Hendrix Experience Electric Ladyland; Simon & Garfunkel Bookends; Berio Sinfonia; Arvo Pärt Credo; Tavener The Whale

Next up: Four Organs (1970)

Published post no.3,083 – Thursday 19 November 2026

New music – Robin Guthrie & Harold Budd: Music from the Film ‘Mysterious Skin’ – Reissue (4AD)

posted by Ben Hogwood text from press release

Harold Budd and Robin Guthrie‘s iconic score for Gregg Araki’s Mysterious Skin (2004) joins the 4AD catalogue with its first vinyl release and CD reissue, which has been long out of print, on 29 January 2027. Along with the release, two ‘Mysterious Skin’ ringer t-shirts will be available exclusively via the 4AD store.

Remastered for 24-bit audio by Guthrie and cut to vinyl by Rashad Becker, Mysterious Skin’s sound-world is at once crystalline and ensconced in reverb – the result of two artists with distinct voices dovetailing, creating as one. Budd and Guthrie’s use of sustained chords, sympathetic drones, and delays created a unique musical language for Araki’s meditation on trauma and memory, acting in both sympathy and counterpoint.

An original proponent of the New Queer Cinema, Araki’s simultaneously sensitive and disquieting treatment of trauma in Mysterious Skin has proved resonant with today’s film lovers. A recent 4k restoration and re-release of the film to celebrate its 20th Anniversary also prompted a whole new audience to find succor in its soundtrack. Originally only released on CD and now long out of print, the music can at present only be heard on widely-streamed, unofficial YouTube uploads, prompting an official remaster and reissue by 4AD in 2027.

Gregg Araki said: “I’ve been a huge fan of Robin and Harold’s since the 80’s glory days when 4AD, Cocteau Twins and The White Arcades ruled and shaped my world. This music has been such an essential part of my life and such a profound influence on me and my work. I always listen to music when I write – as does Scott Heim, author of the original novel Mysterious Skin – so this soundtrack is much, much more than mere background music: it’s the heart and soul of the whole movie. The dreamy poetic nature of both the book and the film comes directly from this style of music – and the incredible score Robin and Harold have composed is so evocative and breathtakingly gorgeous, it literally brought me to tears the first time I heard it.”

The pair’s working practices informed Mysterious Skin‘s deeply evocative music. The cues in the film were recorded by each artist remotely before being woven together by Guthrie for the soundtrack. Budd focused primarily on piano and synthesizer, while Guthrie employed his trademark shimmering guitar and subtle electronic treatments. The seamless, cohesive universe created by the artists is testament to the way they fit together as personalities. Working independently to pre-audio cuts of the film, the musicians composed the cues which would be the basis of the soundtrack album. Harold Budd’s playing – instantly recognizable and influential – unfurls like pillows of cushioned memory over the film. Robin Guthrie performs his signature processed guitars, at times more structured with beats and other instruments, and exploits his already-iconic musical language.

Indeed, the sensitive, spacious music created by Budd and Guthrie creates a womb-like safety in which Mysterious Skin‘s narrative unfolds. A film about the complex consequences of childhood trauma, the plot follows the two main characters’ differing journeys following the same event. On Neil’s Theme, Guthrie’s chiming notes and chordal shimmer dance with light and shade, mirroring Araki’s subtle tonal shifts in the film. Waterfalls of guitar sparkle against smeared reverb, ghostly drones and overtones seeping into the spaces between the notes on Twilight. Budd’s sparse piano introduces moments of tension and dissonance: on The Discovery, piano notes dance over clouds of echo, unresolved notes hinting at the sense of unease that is sewn into the film’s fabric. In the heartbreaking final scene, Snowfall echoes the snow falling on screen as layers of guitar and reverb trails mirror the humanity portrayed.

Throughout the extended soundtrack, the reciprocity and deep respect the artists have for each other created a mutual language that only grew over time, resulting in another two decades of albums, soundtracks and performances. On Mysterious Skin, their music serves as a guiding hand to the narrative – an integral element of the storytelling that also stands alone as a venerated cult album that is finally being made available in new and remastered formats.

Music from the Film Mysterious Skin will be available on CD and Standard Black LP from 29 January 2027. Mysterious Skin ringer t-shirts (navy/white and white/red) and a very limited number of hand-stamped white labels will be available exclusively via the 4AD store. For more information, and to order, head to the 4AD Shop

Published post no.3,082 – Wednesday 18 November 2026

Switched On – OR: Music For Empty Stadiums (4AD)

Reviewed by Ben Hogwood

What’s the story?

Music For Empty Stadiums is the work of Oriol Riverola, better known to electronic music fans as John Talabot – whose ƒIN was one of the albums of 2012.

His approach here is very different to that winning hybrid of disco and house, with a 95-minute album whose roots are in lockdown. Initially Riverola would listen to music at full volume in his studio in Barcelona, looking to fill the void that had opened up in place of DJing and live appointments, but then he realised that a ‘new normal’ might only mean music of an ambient persuasion. He therefore sought a way of dressing the euphoria of full-blooded dancefloor action in ambient clothes.

What’s the music like?

Remarkably, for those familiar with Riverola’s previous work, Music For Empty Stadiums is almost entirely beatless. Yet somehow those beats are implied, the rhythms fully present in music that dances at a much higher frequency.

Listening to the album is like walking out into bright sunlight, for there are some striking strobe effects present in tracks like Barroque, or a constant, insistent flickering of light that runs through the likes of Terrace. Often Riverola’s music behaves like an elusive butterfly (Where’s The Melody) but can also evoke images with uncanny accuracy, such as Ginger & Miyake, which has the feel of listening to the buzz of friendly crickets on holiday.

There are thrills and spills to be had here – the rush of Supper Bowl, for instance – while Maracaná is like hearing the club from a distance – killer riffs, snatches of treble, but very little bass. Fractal Love Odyssey is an epic along similar lines, while the busy Strings Of Death flickers hypnotically.

Does it all work?

It does – the rarefied, dreamy atmosphere holds the whole way through. It is a remarkable balancing act between restful states and rest…and also begs the question of how a remix album of these productions would work. It would be intriguing to see if Riverola already has that up his sleeve.

Is it recommended?

Enthusiastically. This is a unique album, of equal parts energy and ambience, and it leaves a lasting spell. A go-to listen for colour and positivity.

For fans of…Daniel Avery, John Hopkins, Lindstrøm, HAAi

Listen / Buy

Published post no.3,081 – Tuesday 17 November 2026

Pulse Music – Steve Reich: Violin Phase (1967)

by Ben Hogwood

“The listener thus becomes aware of one pattern in the music that may open his ear to another, and another, all sounding simultaneously in the ongoing overall texture.” – Steve Reich, in his programme note for Violin Phase (from Steve Reich: Writings on Music: 1965-2000)

Background

“The piece was basically an expansion and refinement of Piano Phase in two ways”, says the composer in the Writings on Music booklet note. “First, there were four voices moving against each other instead of only two, as in Piano Phase; second, and perhaps more important, I became clearly aware of the many melodic patterns resulting from the combination of two or more identical instruments playing the same repeating pattern one or more beats out of phase with each other.”

Paul Griffiths, writing in his notes to accompany the work’s first recording from Shem Guibbory on ECM, notes the piece is “All the time repeating the same simple but elegantly irregular twelve-beat module. The first three parts move increasingly out of synchrony and produce unexpected patterns, some of which are enhanced by the fourth part. The process is at once mechanical and lively.”

There is a thorough guide to performing Violin Phase, written for The Strad by Pwyll ap Siôn, covering technical and musical aspects. The best way to appreciate the piece, however, is to watch London Sinfonietta violinist Jonathan Morton at work in the brilliantly worked video below:

Listen

Thoughts

Violin Phase is the piece that confirmed that Steve Reich’s phased approach to composition had legs beyond the medium of tape. Though a companion piece to Piano Phase, it is very different – and gets very little credit or exposure as a critical piece in his output. Here the composer began to look beyond an instrument he could play, or a medium in which he was comfortable recording, considering the possibilities of new timbres, new colours.

Intriguingly, it is the most obviously American work of Reich’s instrumental output so far – with the open strings that play a critical part of the violin’s phrasing really evoking the open prairie in a way Copland might have done. There is a also an extremely strong rhythmic emphasis, the piece dancing freely and openly, especially when the violin is exposed on the open strings.

By the time all four parts are in play the ear is congested, but in a good way, with so many melodic fragments and riffs to latch on to. The musical mind can either latch on to one repeating strain, or go for a wander across all the figures in play.

Quotes / Legacy

Violin Phase was used in 1982 by Belgian choreographer Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker to form the second movement of Fase, one of her key dance works:

Recordings

There are three key recordings. The Jonathan Morton example video above was singled out by Reich himself as being “the most satisfactory version that I’ve ever heard and seen”. Yet the two on this Tidal playlist, from Shem Guiborry (ECM) and Jagdish Mistry (RCA) are both very fine too. Interestingly Morton takes his time more, clocking in two minutes longer than the other two.

Also written / released in 1967 The Doors The Doors; The Velvet Underground The Velvet Underground & Nico; Lutosławski Symphony no.2; Ligeti Lontano

Next up: Pendulum Music (1968)

Published post no.3,080 – Monday 16 November 2026

In concert – John Holiday & Kevin Miller @ Wigmore Hall

John Holiday (countertenor), Kevin Miller (piano)

Programme from album Over My Head including pieces by H Leslie Adams, Theodore Morrison, Robert Leigh Morris, Carlos Simon and George Gershwin. Full repertoire list at the bottom of this review

Wigmore Hall, London
Friday 13 November 2026

by John Earls. Photo credits (below) John Earls

John Holiday has a voice and personality that radiate warmth and conviction. The American countertenor, who performs on both opera and concert stage, has recently released his debut classical album, Over My Head, accompanied by pianist and best friend Kevin Miller. It’s an album that in his sleeve notes he advises “has been a long time in the making” with the music “carefully chosen for its powerful messages of hope, love and resilience”.

Looking resplendent in a striking green jacket, electric blue trousers and black spangled boots as he comes on stage at the Wigmore Hall for a lunchtime performance of the album (or at least most of it) with Miller, it’s clear from the outset that we are in the company of someone who also exudes brightness.

The set opens, as does the album, with Hall Johnson’s composition of the traditional spiritual text I’m Gonter Tell God All O’ My Troubles in which Holiday gives a real sense of yearning for inner peace and an early indication of the depth and range of expression in his singing.

That depth and range is also apparent when Holiday uses his voice to communicate without words in the two piano-accompanied textless vocal pieces in the programme, Carlos Simon’s Vocalise I and II, the latter giving a sense of contentedness and assurance (Vocalise III from the album was not performed due to time constraints).

There then follows Theodore Morrison’s 5 Songs on poems by James Joyce which highlights Millar’s deft piano playing such as on No. 1 Strings in the earth and air, with floating notes to Holiday’s soft singing and the twinkling accompaniment in the final section of the beautiful and mournful No. 4 Now, O now in this brown land. Things are brisker in the short No. 3 Lightly come or lightly go and vigorous No. 5 I hear an army with its urgent start and finish.

In a change to the album’s running order the next section features four pieces from H Leslie Adams’ Nightsongs: Prayer is delicate and beautiful, The Heart of a Woman sombre and meaningful, Night Song contains some dramatic closing piano flourishes, and Sence You Went Away, a real highlight of the concert, is exquisite in its sadness and sense of loss with exceptional timing and delivery in the second verse.

“At my core, I am a church boy,” says Holiday in the programme and album notes and we move on to what he tells us is his “gospel set” and three pieces from Robert Leigh Morris’s Lyric Suite starting with the jaunty Humoresque. Holiday then leaves the stage to emerge from the side door and sing the glorious Gospel Blues whilst walking up and down both aisles of the hall singing, “Oh my lord, what shall I do?”. It’s a powerful and affecting four minutes before he returns to the stage for the bright Juba: Ev’rytime I Feel the Spirit.

Holiday then sits solo at the piano to sing and play his own arrangements of three songs starting with George Gershwin’s Summertime from Porgy and Bess which is bouncy and well received, and then a moving rendition of Abel Meeropol’s Strange Fruit. Limited time means we don’t get to hear his arrangement of Bart Howard’s Fly Me to the Moon which is a jewel on the album.

Finally, there is the traditional Over My Head and Amazing Grace with Holiday encouraging the audience to sing the phrase “praise love” in the middle and for the next verse he changes the opening line from “So, over my head, I hear music in the air” to “I just heard music in the air”. His singing of “Somewhere! I believe there is a God somewhere” conveys a certainty of faith in the existence of a God with an uncertainty of whereabouts.

There is just time for a short encore, with Holiday conducting more audience participation for the gospel song This Little Light of Mine.

On a wintry November day and in a cold Wigmore Hall (where the audience kept their coats and scarves on) Holiday and Miller spread warmth and joy in this fantastic lunchtime recital.

They performed the following repertoire:

Hall Johnson I’m Gonter Tell God All O’ My Troubles
Carlos Simon I. from Vocalise
Theodore Morrison Chamber Music: 5 Songs on poems by James Joyce – No. 1 Strings in the earth and air • No. 2 O cool is the valley now • No. 3 Lightly come or lightly go • No. 4 Now, O now in this brown land • No. 5 I hear an army
Carlos Simon II. from Vocalise
H Leslie Adams from Nightsongs – Prayer • The Heart of a Woman • Night Song • Sence You Went Away
Robert Leigh Morris from Lyric Suite – III. Humoresque • II. Gospel Blues • V. Juba: Ev’rytime I Feel the Spirit
Gershwin arr Holiday Summertime from Porgy and Bess
Meeropol arr Holiday Strange Fruit
Traditional Over My Head; Amazing Grace
Gospel song: This Little Light of Mine (Encore)

Over My Head by John Holiday with Kevin Miller is released by Pentatone. For more details visit the Pentatone website

John Earls writes the weekly Substack column Hanging Out a Window (you can subscribe for free here: https://johnearls.substack.com/) and posts at @johnearls.bsky.social on Bluesky and @john_earls on X.

Published post no.3,079 – Sunday 15 November 2026