by Ben Hogwood

Today (23 February) saw the conclusion of BBC Radio 2’s Piano Room month, which has been taking place every weekday for the last month.

For anyone new to the concept, it consists of a well-known pop artist delivering three songs in the company of a piano and the BBC Concert Orchestra. Generally they follow the format of something old, something new and something borrowed (which may of course be blue!) in the form of a cover version. We began with Bruce Hornsby on Monday 31 January (a performance already appraised by Arcana) and ended today with Pet Shop Boys.

The Piano Room has proved to be an enormously uplifting spectacle over the last few years, and a fascinating one too – the equivalent of watching a famous actor appearing on the West End stage. There are two things that often shine through in the course of a session. One is obvious, being the artistry of the main act in question, and their ability to breathe new life into their songs or well-chosen covers. The other is not so immediate, being the quality of the orchestral arrangements and the sheer ability of the BBC Concert Orchestra, who deliver their lines with incredible poise and great expression.

Here, then, are five top performances Arcana has had the pleasure to hear this month, in addition to the Bruce Hornsby already reviewed…bearing in mind that as I type this I haven’t yet heard Pet Shop Boys doing Left To My Own Devices!

Rick Astley – Never Gonna Give You Up

The sign of a song with ultimate staying power is its versatility – and when it can be sung like this, in a version that bears very little resemblance to the original, you realise again just what a brilliant song this is. Somehow the arrangers and Rick have worked in a pizzicato part for the violins that comes from Ed Sheeran’s Shape Of You – a very different love song, but one that fits this template hand in glove.

It also shows how Rick Astley has grown as a vocalist, making music that matches his experience but also his youthful approach:

Olivia Dean – Suzanne (Leonard Cohen cover)

This is an extraordinary cover version from Olivia Dean. Sumptuous strings begin and end the arrangement (made by Sam Gale) and Dean sings in a way that recognizes Leonard Cohen’s ability to wring great emotion from relative simplicity. She intones the verse and brings a swell to the chorus, giving the song a deep resonance. This is capped by the fragility of the closing violin solo, a moment of pure but devastating clarity (played – I am almost sure – by Charles Mutter). I haven’t been able to keep a dry eye watching it yet!

Jess Glynne – Everywhere (Fleetwood Mac cover)

This was a very pleasant surprise. I find I respect Jess Glynne rather than connecting directly with her music, though her Rather Be collaboration with Clean Bandit and her own Don’t Be So Hard On Yourself have shown their staying course, and Hold My Hand is on a TV advert several times a day. I wasn’t prepared for how much I would warm to this cover – sensitively done, a lovely ‘less is more’ vocal sung with evident affection, and some great work from the band (especially bass player Dishan Abrahams). Casting aside a well played but rather unnecessary reference to David Bowie’s Under Pressure towards the end, this is a beautifully made cover, which you can view from 16’50” on this link

Crowded House – Four Seasons In One Day

This short song gains an unexpectedly emotive orchestral prelude, made possible through a broad cello solo to set the scene before the song comes in. Neil and Tim Finn’s evocative songwriting makes an effortless leap from intimate voice and guitar to band and orchestra, telling the story in just as much detail as before – yet boosted by a beautiful string arrangement. You can view from the start of this link

Gabrielle – A Place In Your Heart

How does Gabrielle do it?! For 30 years now she has held the keys to an increasing array of radio friendly songs, and under the guise of an orchestra they blossom into even fuller colours. This, her most recent single, is a beauty – and touchingly sung, too, in an arrangement that adds a great deal of depth to the song. You can view from 7’23” on this link

And finally…what a lovely tribute the orchestra gave to Radio 2 DJ Steve Wright, playing his Big Show jingle in tribute to the DJ who died unexpectedly on 13 February:

You can watch the full set of Bruce Hornsby in the Radio 2 Piano Room by clicking here

Published post no.2,097 – Friday 23 February 2024