Tag Archives: classical-music

Arcana at the BBC Proms – Augustin Hadelich, Berliner Philharmoniker / Kirill Petrenko: Beethoven & Scriabin

Posted on by
Reply

Augustin Hadelich (violin), Berliner Philharmoniker / Kirill Petrenko

Beethoven Violin Concerto in D major Op.61 (1806)
Scriabin Symphony no.3 in C minor, Op.43 ‘Le poème divin’ (1902-04)

Royal Albert Hall, London
Thursday 3 September 2026

Reviewed by Richard Whitehouse Photos (c) BBC / Chris Christodoulou

Their second appearance this season saw Kirill Petrenko and the Berliner Philharmoniker tackling pieces that, written almost a century apart, could hardly have offered greater contrast in terms of their aesthetic and which made the cohesion of tonight’s programme the more impressive.

His fifth visit to the Proms in just a decade found Augustin Hadelich giving a performance of Beethoven’s Violin Concerto full of interest if on occasion neglecting the wood for the trees. Not that, other than momentarily in its development, the opening Allegro hung fire but this most spacious such movement in Beethoven’s output lacked an underlying impetus without which it all too easily loses focus. The (unexpected) highlight was a Kreisler cadenza which renewed respect for its motivic ingenuity then segued into the coda with acute seamlessness.

There was little to fault thereafter. The Larghetto duly emerged as the most eloquent of those variational slow movements that Beethoven favoured at this time, with orchestral playing of fastidious poise then an ideal transition into the final Rondo – the incisiveness of whose main theme threw into relief its genial secondary idea then the plaintiveness of its central episode. It rounded off what was a never less than perceptive reading, and Hadelich returned with his own arrangement of Träumerei from Schumann‘s Kinderszenen as a raptly affecting encore.

Some 98 years after Beethoven’s most intrinsically abstract symphonic work found Scriabin flexing his extra-musical muscles in the last if most ambitious of his numbered symphonies. Given its UK premiere at these concerts by Sir Henry Wood in 1918 and repeated three years later, The Divine Poem had to wait nine decades for its Proms revival but has now secured its place in the repertoire. Certainly there was no element of ‘special pleading’ in an account as underlined that structural integration between its three (continuous) movements as across the work overall. However overreaching Scriabin’s theosophical aspirations may have been, his musical instinct was such that nothing is left to chance in a design as surveys the ‘tragedy to triumph’ trajectory beloved of late-Romanticism from an arresting and productive vantage.

The defining motto drawn unerringly into its evolution, the opening Luttes made a virtue of its discursive unfolding with a sure balance between its agitated and ethereal themes; building to a resplendent if short-lived climax in its development then methodically retracing its steps. There was no lack of sensuousness in the central Voluptés, offset by an ominous undertow resolved in the final Jeu divin with its capricious trumpet idea and its pointed revisiting of earlier material as made the eventual apotheosis not just inevitable but necessary as a formal and expressive QED. Felicities of phrasing and of texture abounded in an interpretation that demonstrated the rapport of conductor and orchestra, now at the start of their eighth season together, at its most tangible with music on the cusp between Romanticism and Modernism.

As on their earlier visits, there was no encore with Petrenko’s blowing a kiss to the audience his most overt acknowledgement of what seemed a genuine enthusiasm for the piece as heard in this performance. Their next Proms appearance (in 2028?) can only be eagerly anticipated.

You can listen to this Proms concert on BBC Sounds until the end of September 2026.

Published post no.3.007 – Friday 4 September 2026

On Record: Royal Ballet Sinfonia / Pete Harrison: Adam Saunders Orchestral Music (Heritage Records)

Posted on by
Reply

Royal Ballet Sinfonia / Pete Harrison, Gavin Sutherland (The Magical Kingdom), Barry Wordsworth (Journey to Lapland)

Adam Saunders
The Magical Kingdom (2003)
Fairytale Sleighride (2008)
Journey to Lapland (2020)
Ballet for Strings (2025)
Capriccio (2025)
Parade of the Snowman (2025)
Sinfonietta (2025)
Sketches of New York (2025)
Three Pieces (2025)

Heritage Records HTGCD117 [68’12”]
Producer Philip Lane Engineers Tony Faulkner, Mike Ross-Trevor (The Magical Kingdom)

Recorded 4 February 2023 at CTS, Wembley (The Magical Kingdom), 12 September 2023 (Journey to Lapland) and 2, 3 January 2026 (all other works) at Henry Wood Hall, London

Reviewed by Richard Whitehouse

What’s the story?

His work having featured on several of its miscellanies, Heritage now issues an album devoted to the music of Adam Sanders (b.1968); his skill when navigating various genres and blurring of easy distinctions between ‘light’ or ‘serious’ music made evident throughout this collection.

What’s the music like?

His music often having an illustrative or pictorial aspect does not lessen Saunders’ technical command in a medium for which he has keen affinity. This is as evident in the earlier pieces here as in those more recent works that, between them, make up the larger part of this album.

The curtain-raiser that is Capriccio having launched proceedings with wit and insouciance, Three Pictures demonstrates Saunders’ all-round versatility across three movements which take in the animated Fanfare and Celebrations, the raptly evocative landscape conjured by Rivers of Calm, Peaks of Magnificence, then the final burst of activity conveyed through Dances of Exuberance. With its often resourceful scoring for strings and harp, Sketches of New York is the highlight of this collection – whether in the pulsating while never mindless activity which characterizes Bustling Metropolis, the elegiac expression of Lonely Souls, the lilting elegance of Green Dances, or the lively and joyful abandon of A City at Play.

If the sprightly and entertaining march-past that is Parade of the Snowman has not become a regular seasonal fixture on Classic FM, it certainly ought to be. As, for that matter, should The Magical Kingdom which subtly refits the British light music from an earlier era for the present day. It lasts barely 10 minutes overall, but Sinfonietta cannily outlines a symphony   in miniature as it moves from the spirited incisiveness of its initial Allegro, via the tranquil eloquence of its Adagio then the humorous resolve of its Scherzo, to the brilliant display of its final Allegro. One of the relatively few abstract compositions in Saunders’ output, this is also one of the most appealing and it would be worth the composer building on its promise.

Fairytale Sleighride finds Saunders back on familiar ground and what is another miniature made for Christmas with tuned percussion to the fore. More substantial (indeed the longest overall work on this collection) is Ballet for Strings – its five movements at once dance-like though self-sufficient in content as they take in expressive characters which are respectively humorous in intent; gracious while not a little nostalgic; animated but with searching asides; delicate in scoring if robust in spirit; then energetic to a degree that sees the overall sequence through to a decisive close. It only remains for Journey to Lapland to round off proceedings with its ‘adventure’ being played out for the pleasure and enjoyment of listeners everywhere.

Does it all work?

It does. Those having heard Saunders’ overture Pirates Ahoy! (Dutton CDLX7190) or one of the seasonal pieces on Heritage’s Christmas anthologies (HTGCD139 and HTGCD299) will find much to enjoy, not least with the Royal Ballet Sinfonia so attuned to his attractive idiom.

Is it recommended?

It is, not least as enhanced with excellent sound produced by and informative booklet notes written by Philip Lane, among the leading British light-music composers of his generation. Hopefully there will be further opportunities to hear Saunders’ orchestral work before long.

Listen / Buy

You can explore purchase options at the Heritage Records website. Click on the names for more information on composer Adam Saunders, the Royal Ballet Sinfonia and conductors Pete Harrison, Gavin Sutherland and Barry Wordsworth

Published post no.3,003 – Tuesday 1 September 2026

On Record – Raphael Wallfisch, BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra / Kenneth Woods – John McCabe: Symphonies 2 & 3 and Cello Concerto (Signum Classics)

Posted on by
Reply

Raphael Wallfisch (cello), BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra / Kenneth Woods

John McCabe
Symphony no.2 (1970-71)
Symphony no.3 ‘Hommages’ (1978)
Cello Concerto ‘Songline’ (2007)

Signum Classics SIGCD1007 [67’32”]
Producer Andrew Keener Engineer Oscar Torres, Matthew Swan

Recorded 9-11 June 2025 at City Halls, Glasgow

Reviewed by Richard Whitehouse

What’s the story?

Signum Classics makes a notable addition to the discography of John McCabe (1939-2015) with his Second and Third Symphonies, alongside his Cello Concerto, given committed and perceptive performances from the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra with Kenneth Woods.

What’s the music like?

Ranging over four decades, McCabe’s seven symphonies are a defining factor of his output and his achievement overall. An ability to reassess the genre afresh each time is hardly less true of those 20 or so concertos which, between them, encompass the entirety of his career.

Certain listeners may have encountered the Second Symphony via Louis Frémaux’s recording (EMI/Warner) made soon after the premiere. The catalyst was Sam Peckinpah’s Western The Wild Bunch (1969) and though McCabe does not follow this hard-hitting scenario literally, he does chart its emotional and maybe its experiential trajectory. A speculative woodwind phrase pervades the single movement whose five sections purposefully alternate fast and slow tempi, incisive and reflective moods, on its course to a visceral while cathartic denouement. That the work emerges full circle, the same yet different, comes as no surprise given its inspiration in a film which was unyielding in its fatalism but highly enlightening through its innate realism.

The stylistic consistency of McCabe’s idiom across several decades is borne out by his Cello Concerto, the ‘Songline’ of whose subtitle references that route taken through its content by the listener akin to aboriginals tracing a physical path through the Australian terrain; even a psychological path through their culture. Tersely though cogently argued, its outer Allegros frame a lengthy Adagio that takes in elements of slow movement and scherzo – separated by an accompanied cadenza where the soloist interacts with luminous tuned percussion in what ranks among its composer’s most eloquent inspirations. Neither are those closing bars, their abruptness dispelling any equivocation, seem other than inevitable in terms of a conclusion.

Stemming from what was a productive period for the genre in the UK, the Third Symphony is a highlight of McCabe’s output. The ‘Hommages’ of its subtitle makes reference to Haydn and Nielsen – but any such allusions are merged into a cumulative structure whose three (more or less) continuous movements unfold from an oblique if stealthy sonata design, via a ‘Fantasia’ more intermezzo than slow movement, to a ‘Fugue-Variations’ which gradually propels the whole orchestra towards an inexorable culmination with resplendent brass then ricocheting percussion. One of the most visceral endings in the modern symphonic repertoire that made an audible impression at its premiere, 48 years ago, and would doubtless do so again today.

Does it all work?

Yes, not least with Woods so attuned to McCabe’s idiom: the Second Symphony less taut if more flexible than Frémaux’s pioneering account and the Third a reminder of why Charles Dutoit’s premiere left such an impact. Nor is Raphael Wallfisch at all wanting in Songlines.

Is it recommended?

Indeed, enhanced by spacious yet detailed sound with informative notes from Guy Rickards. Hopefully Woods and the BBCSSO will take McCabe’s final two symphonies into the studio, while such major works as the Third Piano and Second Violin Concertos also await recording.

Listen / Buy

You can explore purchase options at the Signum Records website, and listen to excerpts from the album at Presto Music. Click on the names to read more about composer John McCabe, cellist Raphael Wallfisch, the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra and conductor Kenneth Woods

Published post no.2,986 – Tuesday 17 August 2026

Arcana at the BBC Proms – Soloists, Epiphoni Consort, BBC Symphony Chorus & Orchestra / Nil Venditti: Respighi & Rossini

Posted on by
Reply

Federica Lombardi (soprano), Chiara Amarù (mezzo-soprano), Dave Monaco (tenor), Nicola Ulivieri (bass), Epiphoni Consort, BBC Symphony Chorus and Orchestra / Nil Venditti

Respighi Church Windows (Vetrate di chiesa) (1925-26)
Rossini Stabat Mater (1831-1841)

Royal Albert Hall, London
Friday 7 August 2026

Reviewed by Ben Hogwood Photos (c) BBC / Mark Allan

Friday night is Italian night at the BBC Proms, it would seem. Two weeks after John Wilson’s blistering account of Respighi’s Roman Trilogy, we had a sequel of sorts headed by Italian-Turkish conductor Nil Venditti, marshalling a double bill from Respighi and Rossini, a composer he much admired.

As we heard two weeks back, Respighi was no shrinking violet when writing for orchestra, a point reemphasised by this first Proms performance of Church Windows. This is the sort of orchestral music on which the Royal Albert Hall thrives – descriptive, colourful, bold, brash in places but beautifully controlled in others. One of these moments was Adam Lee’s clarinet solo, exquisitely spun.

Less obviously demonstrative than the Roman poems, Church Windows nonetheless softened the heart with its invocations of Gregorian chants and chorales, woven into Respighi’s writing. Not all were successful in performance, the horn theme of San Michele Arcangelo taking a while to align with Venditti’s tempo, but this movement grew into a tumultuous finish, the tam-tam describing Satan’s fall from heaven. A tender account of Il mattutino di Santa Chiara (The Matins of St Clare) found the BBC SO woodwind on fine form, but the finale, San Gregorio Magno (St Gregory the Great) carried all before it, Richard Pearce’s barnstorming organ solo briefly smothering the orchestra before a brilliantly manoeuvred climax. Once again, the ears were ringing, and while this may not have registered so highly on the Richter scale, it was nonetheless a qualified triumph.

Rossini’s Stabat Mater is similarly unconventional. Its long gestation period would suggest a creative block, but the final composition, finished after a decade, is a profound utterance. Venditti kept things moving here, and with an evident love for the piece, from the solemn choral intoning of the Stabat mater dolorosa itself, through the sequence of arias which found the soloists taking a little while to adjust to the acoustic of the hall. A healthy balance was found, though bass Nicola Ulivieri, a commanding presence, was appreciably louder than his three colleagues – each of whom were dramatic in their responses to the text. Tenor Dave Monaco nailed his top notes with impressive precision in the Cujus animam gementem, soprano Federica Lombardi was bright and commendably unforced with the chorus throughout Inflammatus et accensus, while mezzo-soprano Chiara Amarù shone in the Fac, ut portem Christi mortem.

Yet the real stars of this performance were the London-based Epiphoni Consort, making their Proms debut, and the BBC Symphony Chorus, both extremely well drilled and of one voice. The antiphonal exchanges of ‘Paradisi gloria’ in the Quando corpus morietur section were memorable, but the crowning glory was the ‘Amen’ finale, where Rossini – and the charismatic Venditti – let loose in the thrilling tour de force of powerful counterpoint. A special mention for timpanist Antoine Bedewi, too, whose role throughout was critical. This was the choir’s to bring home, however, and they delivered with style and panache, convincing audience and listeners of Rossini’s original inspiration and dramatic instinct. A refreshingly different Prom, and how good to hear two less familiar but deserving works in performances that made them shine.

You can listen to this Proms concert on BBC Sounds until the end of September 2026.

Published post no.2,977 – Saturday 8 August 2026

In concert – National Youth Orchestra / Thomas Adès: Transcend – Liszt, Adès & Berlioz

Posted on by
Reply

National Youth Orchestra / Thomas Adès

Liszt Mephisto Waltz No. 1, S110 No. 2 (1856-61)
Adès Dante, Part 2: Purgatorio (2019-20)
Berlioz Symphonie fantastique Op.14 (1830)

Symphony Hall, Birmingham
Wednesday 5 August 2026

Reviewed by Richard Whitehouse Photos (c) Tom Morley

If there is little space remaining on an extended Symphony Hall platform, the National Youth Orchestra is the likely reason. Tonight saw the start of its annual summer tour with a typically demanding programme that played to the strengths of some 150 players in no small measure.

All three of these pieces are focussed upon a journey of unforeseen consequences, not least Liszt’s First Mephisto Waltz. Setting a swift tempo for its propulsive initial section, Thomas Adès ensured the performance had the measure of this and of those halting evocations at its centre. If the sudden build-up to its climax felt a little tentative, the ensuing pensiveness and hectic coda (this being the more familiar loud ending) found these musicians comfortably in control. A showpiece with substance that deserves to regain its popularity from former times.

Adès’s ballet Dante has been often heard on stage or in concert. Its central Purgatorio makes a journey from out of darkness towards light, recordings of three sung prayers made the basis for its musical evolution. This would be fine were that evolution more varied in progress and more cumulative in impact. As it was, samples of this chanting were elaborated by woodwind and brass, singly or in ‘choirs’, before drawing to a climax on full orchestra. That this process was several times repeated would not have mattered had it been less systematic or predictable, while the actual writing had (surprisingly) little subtlety or finesse to offset its brazen impact. Whatever Adès’s orchestral command or the NYO’s commitment in realizing it, the result felt not so far removed from Wojciech Kilar’s folk-inspired symphonic poems half a century ago.

Berlioz’s Symphonie fantastique is a work that has featured often on NYO schedules, but its music is tailor-made for an orchestra with not a few aspiring professionals to demonstrate its capabilities, and the present performance did not disappoint. Favouring relatively swift tempi, Adès steered an impulsive if never wayward course through Rêveries – Passions; at its best in the approach to a searing climax followed by its pensive ‘come down’. He found the right balance between elegance and ecstasy in Un bal (but this was not a waltz for dancing), then traversed Scène aux champs with due focus on that mounting despair which emerges out of then returns to the soulful isolation either side. The thunder effects of multiple timpani at its close were well realized, while the cor anglais (Leah Wiseman) summoned a melting pathos.

Steady if not unduly portentous (with, as in the first movement, its repeat included), ‘Marche au supplice’ made a properly baleful impact – not least through the addition of military drums after the fall of the guillotine – but it was a pity Adès did not head straight into Songe d’une nuit de sabbat, whose initial silence then feels more deafening. That said, he had the measure of its sardonic parodies of earlier themes, evocations of gothic horror and fugal orgies on the way to an apotheosis during which the NYO gave its collective all then some more besides.

The result was a performance that could not have failed to impress those unfamiliar with this singular work. Doubtless the programme overall will sound equally impressive with the NYO repeating in at Snape Maltings tomorrow evening, then at the Royal Albert Hall this Saturday.

To read more about the NYO’s 2026 summer tour, visit the NYO website – and click on the name to read more about composer & conductor Thomas Adès

Published post no.2,971 – Friday 7 August 2026